The Innovation Project

The Knight News Challenge is made up of many diverse and sophisticated entries that contribute to a major area of advancement in both the fields of journalism and technology. From 2007-2009, winners in the Knight News Challenge have received various sums of grant money in order to make their proposal a reality. Several criteria for consideration in the Knight News Challenge include use of digital media, open source availability to users, specific geographical location and impact, and the ability of the idea to create and build communities through communication.  I would like to examine a few of the past winners and see where their strengths and weaknesses lie so that my proposal can implement or avoid certain aspects of these projects.

From the 2009 winners of the Knight News Challenge, the submission known as DocumentCloud is an interesting concept that could prove quite useful for students or reporters doing in-depth research on a particular story or case. The documents presented on DocumentCloud will be original source documents that will be contributed to the site by various news organizations. The sources may also include news bloggers and freelance reporters as well. The goal is to be an open source media outlet that allows not only for submission but also commentary and review. In a way, it works as a worldwide think tank for anyone who wishes to participate.

Another big winner in 2009 was the MediaBugs proposal. This particular website would act as a channel to allow readers and writers to be able to correct or identify errors in existing news stories. This is another example of complete open-sourced media, connecting the story’s author with person who found the error, and thus creating a dialogue about the validity or the importance of the story. This program allows the system to track the status of the story to see if any corrections were necessary, and perhaps most importantly, which news organizations are responsible for the most errors.

In terms of advertising and information, a major winner in 2008 was the Printcasting model. Printcasting is a sort of self-help software for individuals to design and personalize their own news. The person can combine separate news-feeds in a manner that he sees fit; this will help individuals localize their news or have the content tailor-made to complement their hobby or business. The news feed is then sent to their home or place of business electronically. Another big winner from 2008 is the RadioEngage software model that is meant to improve the quality and content of radio news via the internet. Radio broadcasts will be sent out over a news radio station’s website, which will also incorporate transcripts, live streams, video, podcasts and other digital features to enhance the station’s multimedia output.

Everyblock was one of the Knight News Challenge winners for 2007 and is also the recipient of one of the largest sums that the KNC has ever distributed at $1,100,000. The exact premise of Everyblock is stated, “To create, test and release open-source software that links databases to allow citizens of a large city to learn (and act on) civic information about their neighborhood or block.” This continues the trend of linking different sources of information between one another so that a person accessing one portal will, in fact have access to many portals. The largest grant the KNC has ever presented was also given in 2007, to the Center for Future Civic Media, for $5,000,000. The Center is described as “a leadership project designed to encourage community news experiments and new technologies and practices.” The Center was co-founded by one of the primary thinkers of the new web 2.0 journalism, Henry Jenkins. The Center website itself is primarily focused on civic media and community building and acts as a broad-based collection of links to many different citizen journalist projects. The website encourages new startup sites and also welcomes feedback from readers as to what content should be covered in the developing websites.

While many of these websites worked very well at incorporating open-sourced applications and allowing for plenty of reader commentary and feedback, many of them did not provide much localization of their proposal. Several of the entries were incredibly broad in terms of where they wanted their service to be provided. It would be quite difficult for any hyperlocalization to occur under any of these circumstances. The potential audience for MediaBugs and RadioEngage were particularly unclear.

For my project, I would like to create an all-purpose media news outlet whose primary goal was to communicate with the citizens of an area that is not used to quality news coverage on the local level. My hometown of Midland, Texas and neighboring Odessa, Texas was one such area where there was a distinct lack of local coverage. The local news was rarely newsworthy, much of what was found in the newspaper being AP articles or fluff pieces that were used as filler. Equipping the citizenry with the necessary tools and the experience of professional guides, while giving them an online arena to publish in would, I believe, see a drastic improvement in the topics that will most affect the livelihood of the people in the area. Establishing a website with plenty of links to local bloggers and access to each other through social networks such as Facebook and Twitter is also crucial to providing worthwhile content.

Links should be used for other news outlets in the area, but also for any type of national or international coverage that the site may deem relevant. However, since this is a local news organization, the primary focus would be on local coverage. This area of Texas is also close to many small towns in the Big Bend National Park that have a lot of local flavor and are mostly ignored by the news in Midland-Odessa. Coverage of the burgeoning world-class art scene in Marfa and Alpine or the historic rodeo in Pecos is rarely discussed in the larger towns of Midland or Odessa. Allowing plenty of forums for the locals in these areas would hopefully establish more of a diverse presence in the newsroom. This is where the website would greatly benefit from an open source attitude that allows journalists to interact with citizens and vice versa. Feedback would become the lifeblood of this format.

Hopefully this has given you some idea of the approach I would like to take. Primarily, I would like to incorporate a website that uses audio, video, text, podcasts, and social media to enhance user-friendliness. The site could possibly establish chat sessions with various members of the reporting staff and any readers who may be interested. This is an area of the country that desperately needs a new angle on the changing face of news, so bringing the content to them instead of waiting for them to come to it is vital for the survival of real reporting in this area.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: